The student-generated news site of Mount Saint Joseph Academy

The Campanile

The student-generated news site of Mount Saint Joseph Academy

The Campanile

The student-generated news site of Mount Saint Joseph Academy

The Campanile

Mountie gift guide
Mountie gift guide
Maura Fecak, Staff Writer • December 4, 2023

The holiday season is upon us. If you or a loved one is in need of gift-giving help, look no further. A Mount student is guaranteed to love at...

Salt to the Sea by Ruta Sepetys is a young adult historical fiction novel set in WWII.
Bookmarked!: November HISTORICAL FICTION 2023
December 4, 2023

This month’s theme was Historical Fiction, and we read Salt to the Sea by Ruta Sepetys! A synopsis of the book and our reviews are below. ————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————— While...

The most wonderful time of the year?
The most wonderful time of the year?
Lee Quinn, Editorial Cartoonist • November 30, 2023

A very Mount Thanksgiving
A very Mount Thanksgiving
November 22, 2023
Sarah Mark ‘24, Angelina Baker ‘24, Ava Vavra ‘24, pause to smile for their Junior Ring Mass.
It's just so Ange!
November 14, 2023

What is the Brotherly Shove and why did are there talks of banning the play?

With a 93% success rate for the Eagles and the potential for injury, it’s a topic worth exploring. 
Photo credit: Matt Kartozian-USA TODAY Sports

In recent NFL seasons, the Philadelphia Eagles have gained a reputation for their success with a unique offensive play known as the “Tush Push” or “Brotherly Shove.” This play has raised questions about its safety, and whether it should be allowed in the league. With a 93% success rate for the Eagles and the potential for injury, it’s a topic worth exploring. 

The Brotherly Shove, is a play the Eagles are heavily dominant in, it is often used on crucial downs when just a yard or two is needed, particularly on fourth downs. The play involves Jalen Hurts, the Eagles’ quarterback, lining up under center Jason Kelce, while two other players push Hurts from behind, giving him the necessary push to gain those few yards or inches.

The Eagles’ remarkable 93% success rate with the Brotherly Shove has set them apart from other NFL teams. While other teams have attempted similar plays, none have achieved the same level of effectiveness. The secret behind the Eagles’ success appears to be their personnel, especially the sheer strength and athleticism of Jalen Hurts, who is known to squat and deadlift an impressive 600 pounds. Along with their pro bowler center, Jason Kelce. 

One of the primary arguments against the Brotherly Shove play is the potential risk it poses to player safety. Football is undoubtedly a physically demanding sport with inherent dangers, so why would this play be any different from other plays in the game?  It’s worth noting that two New York Giants players sustained injuries when attempting to mimic the Eagles’ signature play. 

Story continues below advertisement

“I don’t’ that the NFL should ban the play”. Suggesting that it would be an unfair ruling. Bridget Robinson ‘24 said. 

Others in the league might suggest banning the play just out of jealousy, as the Eagles have mastered this play, it gives them a considerable advantage. 

There could be opposition to the Tush Push play at the league level. While 4th-and-1 situations are inherently on the edge of set plays, the Eagles have turned them into an almost guaranteed success with the Tush Push. 

“The Tush Push does give the Eagles an advantage, but that’s because they have practiced it and moved the right players into pieces to make it effective every time” Brooke Hadlock ‘24 said.

Eagles’ head coach, Nick Sirianni, has expressed confidence in their mastery of the Tush Push. He noted after a game against the Miami Dolphins, “We’ve watched the rest of the league, and, quite frankly, they can’t do it like we can.” 

The Tush Push or Brotherly Shove play raises important questions about its place in the NFL. The impressive success rate, coupled with concerns about player safety, calls for a closer look at whether the league should consider regulating or banning this play. As the NFL continues to evolve and prioritize player safety, the fate of the Tush Push remains uncertain, making it a subject of intrigue and debate among football enthusiasts.

View Comments (1)
More to Discover
About the Contributor
Annie Gleba, Co-Editor in Chief
Annie Gleba is currently a Senior at Mount and is in her forth year writing for The Campanile, as Co-Editor in Chief. Annie is also involved in various clubs at the Mount including, For Petes Sake, Gold Key, and Friends Fur Life. She is hoping to carry her knowledge and interest in sports over to the newspaper and help contribute to great articles.
Donate to The Campanile
Our Goal

Comments (1)

All The Campanile Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • V

    Violet BinczewskiNov 21, 2023 at 4:36 pm

    Great article!!! I loved the insight!